Case Study – 4: Rule of Law

delete UPSC Sample Notes [English]

Case Study – 4: Rule of Law

You are the Superintendent of Police (SP) in the district where instances of honour killing are rampant. One day you receive a phone call from a girl informing you of the potential threat to her and her partners’ life from her family as she has decided to marry a boy belonging to a lower caste. Moreover, the local police station is not filing the FIR or granting them protection. You ask her to visit your office but she demands police protection to come out from the hideout as her father’s goons are chasing her.

On further inquiry, you come to know that the girl is the daughter of one of the most powerful Minister of the State and both girl and boy are legally eligible to get married. The family is concerned about the family prestige due to the lower caste of the boy and also of the financial stability of marriage as they both are unemployed. You are under extreme political pressure to charge the boy of kidnapping the girl or else face the consequences.

In such circumstances, point out the ethical dilemma faced by you and options available to you. Also, chalk out the course of action you would prefer to follow. (250 words)

Solution

Facts of the case:

Possibility of honour killing mainly due to non-acceptability of inter-caste marriage.
Couple legally eligible to get married.
Concerns of financial stability of the marriage.
Local police not filing the FIR.
Extreme political pressure of filing a false case against the boy.

Stakeholders involved

The couple
Politician-father of the girl
Local communities
Self (Superintendent of Police-SP)

Values

Tolerance
Humanism
Leadership
Courage
Social justice

Ethical dilemmas

Personal v/s professional ethics: Adhering to the demands of political leaders by not providing protection to the couple or following legal duty to provide safety and security to the couple.
Following social norms v/s ethical norms: Accepting inter-caste marriage is not socially acceptable but moral standards suggest to allow the couple to exercise their free will.

Options available

Options	Merits	Demerits
Allowing the communities to handle the situation themselves.	Meeting expectations of the political leaders.	Against the fundamental rights of the couple. Going against the Constitutional ethos. Putting lives of the couple at risk. May disturb law and order situation.
Providing police protection to the couple and following standard legal procedures.	Opportunity to show administrative leadership. Showing impartial attitude of administration. Avoiding moral dissonance.	May lead to political backlash against the SP. Risk to lives of the couple once police protection is removed. Police administration may face the wrath of local community leaders.

Option (2) should be the correct approach to handle the situation.

Course of action

S.No.	Step	Reason
1.	Initiating preliminary inquiry and validating the facts	Knowing about the circumstances would give an opportunity to better understand the viewpoints of the couple, the community members and the local police officers. It would make sure that there are no vicious motives or any political conspiracy. This would avoid taking any extreme step under false information.
2.	Filing FIR and providing police protection	Protecting the lives of the couple should be of utmost priority.
3.	Providing legal, financial and moral support to the couple	It is the duty of the administration to provide safety and security to the citizens. Also, the couple must be counseled about their financial and moral responsibilities post marriage.
4.	Convincing their parents and community members.	Parents and community members must be initially convinced about the need to respect their children’s individual freedom. They must be given strict warning not to indulge in any form of violence.
5.	Initiating awareness drive against casteism and honour killing	There is need to make the citizens realize that casteism and honor killing are not just illegal but social evils as well.

Measures to deal with the crisis

Initiate steps for attitudinal change to reduce caste prejudices, abolish untouchability and spread the values of liberty, equality, fraternity, etc in the society.
Utilizing Dr Ambedkar scheme for social integration through inter-caste marriages to extend financial incentive to the couple to enable them to settle down in the initial phase of their married life.
The SP must show spirit of service and conviction to ensure justice to the couple. He must ensure that a safe and secure environment is created in the district so that no one should fear of moral policing.
Taking confidence building measures to regain the trust of people on the administration.

The false notions of honour and pride are so deep rooted that people even forget the social bonds of love and emotions with their own children. Thus, the attitudinal change programmes must target the revival of social bonds and realizing them about need to give respect to human lives and compassion.